Friday, 6 December 2013

Album review: GRANT HART - The Argument

Highlights: Morningstar, Is The Sky The Limit, So Far From Heaven, Shine, Shine, Shine, Glorious, For Those Too High Aspiring

On the question of Hüsker Dü: I’m a Grant Hart man. That’s not to say Bob Mould didn’t write a number of terrific songs for the band, but Hart’s songs just hit me harder. And post breakup – not even an album as acclaimed as Copper Blue could convince me Bob has an edge over Grant as a songwriter. Last year’s Silver Age was okay, but it so hopelessly pales in comparison with this songwriting master-class from Grant Hart.

But with all due respect – The Argument shouldn’t have worked. A sprawling, overblown concept album based on Milton’s Paradise Lost? 20 songs, each done in a different style? All the way up to Heaven and all the way down to Hell? A less than great songwriter would have flunked it. Grant Hart succeeds on all counts.

By track 8, you get a clear idea the man can do no wrong, and that’s considering the fact that stylistically he does it all, from Nuggets-like garage rock (“It Was A Most Disturbing Dream”) to power pop (“Glorious”) to old-time jazz (“Underneath The Apple Tree”) – mind that I’ve just mentioned a rather short stretch of 3 songs on side two. Naturally for a concept album this long, some tracks work better than others, but work they all do: Grant knows his way around a strong pop hook or an exciting groove (even if this groove is all a song has to offer, like the hellish instrumental “War In Heaven” or the sweet but uneventful “Golden Chain”). While Grant’s voice pretty much retains its distinctly Bowie-esque quality all the way through, the instrumentation is diverse: there’s a song here that is based on the swirling sound of the accordion and there’s a song here that’s elevated to an absolutely heavenly level by the harmonica.   

Speaking of the actual concept, the whole thing is both impressive and rather daft. Brilliant and far-fetched. But then Grant Hart is merely a popsmith, so you might as well forget all about the fallen angels and apple trees and concentrate on the tunes. By all means, The Argument has some of this year’s best.


No comments:

Post a Comment